The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Hardwood Flooring for Your Home

There’s something timeless about hardwood floors. They add warmth, character, and value to a home like no other material can. Whether you’re building a new house or updating your current space, choosing the right hardwood flooring is a big decision — and one that will impact the look, feel, and function of your home for decades.

But with so many options out there, how do you know which one is right for you? At Jake Bennage Flooring, we specialize in professional hardwood floor installation and help homeowners navigate the process every step of the way. Here’s your ultimate guide to choosing hardwood floors that check every box — from style and durability to budget and lifestyle.

1. Solid vs. Engineered Hardwood: What’s the Difference?

Before you dive into colors and plank sizes, it’s important to understand the two main types of hardwood flooring: solid and engineered.

• Solid hardwood is made from a single piece of wood from top to bottom. It’s known for classic beauty, long-lasting durability, and the ability to be sanded down and refreshed (though we focus on installation, not refinishing).

• Engineered hardwood is made of multiple layers of wood with a real hardwood veneer on top. It’s more stable than solid hardwood in areas that experience humidity or temperature changes, such as rooms with radiant heat or on-grade installations.

Pro tip:  Iit’s important to note that neither solid nor engineered hardwood should be installed in basements or other areas that aren’t fully temperature- and humidity-controlled. These environments can lead to moisture issues and cupping over time. For below-grade spaces, consider durable alternatives like luxury vinyl plank (LVP) that mimic the look of hardwood while handling moisture beautifully.

2. Choose the Right Wood Species

Different wood species offer unique looks, strengths, and price points. Here are some of the most popular choices homeowners love:

• Oak: A classic choice for its durability and timeless grain pattern. It’s great for busy homes and pairs well with just about any style.

• Maple: Lighter and more subtle in grain, maple gives a modern, clean look and stands up well to wear and tear.

• Hickory: Known for its dramatic grain and rustic appeal, hickory is one of the hardest and most durable options available.

• Walnut: Deep, rich tones make walnut a beautiful choice for formal spaces, though it’s slightly softer than oak or hickory.

• Cherry: Offers a warm, rich color that deepens over time, adding elegance to traditional interiors.

Pro tip: If you have pets, kids, or a lot of foot traffic, choose a harder species like oak or hickory for extra durability.

3. Pick a Color and Finish That Match Your Style

Hardwood comes in a wide range of colors and finishes, so you can match it perfectly to your home’s personality.

• Light tones like ash or maple make rooms feel larger and brighter — perfect for modern or Scandinavian-inspired designs.

• Medium tones are versatile and timeless, working well with most styles and hiding dirt and scratches better.

• Dark tones like walnut or espresso bring drama and sophistication, ideal for traditional or formal spaces.

Also think about finish:

• Matte or satin finishes hide wear and tear and feel more natural.

• Glossy finishes offer a polished, elegant look but may show dust and scratches more easily.

4. Consider Plank Width and Length

The size of your planks plays a big role in how your flooring looks and feels.

• Wide planks (5 inches or more): Create a modern, open feel and showcase the wood’s natural grain.

• Narrow planks (2–3 inches): Offer a more traditional look and can make small spaces feel larger.

• Mixed-width planks: Add character and visual interest, especially in rustic or farmhouse-style homes.

Longer planks also reduce seams and give your space a more continuous, high-end look.

5. Think About Lifestyle and Room Use

Where you’re installing hardwood and how you use the space should guide your choices:

• High-traffic areas (like living rooms or hallways): Go with a harder wood species and a satin or matte finish for durability.

• Bedrooms or formal spaces: You can choose softer woods or darker finishes for a cozy, elegant feel.

• Kitchens or entryways: Engineered hardwood is often a smart choice here, as it handles moisture and temperature changes better.

Pro tip: Always use rugs or mats in entryways to protect your hardwood from dirt and water tracked in from outside.

6. Plan for Professional Installation

Even the most beautiful hardwood won’t look its best without expert installation. Professional installers ensure the planks are properly acclimated, subfloors are prepared, and everything is laid with precision — giving you a floor that’s not only stunning but built to last.

At Jake Bennage Flooring, our team has years of experience installing first-quality hardwood flooring in homes across Central Pennsylvania. We handle the details, so all you have to do is enjoy your beautiful new floors.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right hardwood flooring is about more than just picking a color — it’s about finding the perfect balance of style, durability, and practicality for your home and lifestyle. Whether you prefer the warm, rustic charm of hickory or the sleek, modern vibe of maple, the right floor will elevate your space and add lasting value.

Ready to bring timeless hardwood beauty into your home? Call Jake Bennage Flooring today for expert installation and trusted guidance on selecting the best hardwood for your space.